You Struggle with That!?

Responding to a group member who confesses a secret sin

Okay, suppose you're doing a good job leading a small group. You're building relationships among group members, people seem to be growing closer to God, and everything seems to be going swimmingly, when suddenly, Whammo!—one of your group members (or even your co-leader) confesses that they are struggling with a secret sin. Now what do you do?

Well, for starters, the title of this article is not the suggested response. :)

It's important to recognize that confession of sin is a good thing. You shouldn't assume your group is under some sort of spiritual attack. One of the aims of our small groups is (or should be) to create a safe environment where people can grow closer to God. Well, growing closer to God often involves the conviction of the Holy Spirit and the need to repent of sin. If someone's confessing, it means you've done a good job leading your group and you should give yourself a pat on the back. (Okay, you can actually give God the credit, but you get the point.)

So, what sort of sins am I talking about? Not the "Oops! I messed up and said a bad word today" kinds of sin. I'm referring to serious sin patterns in people's lives that they've been convicted of and that they need to deal with. This can also include secret sins that people have been silently struggling with for years.

  • "I'm addicted to pornography."
  • "I'm anorexic."
  • "I'm sleeping with my boyfriend."
  • "I struggle with homosexuality."
  • "I demean and belittle others to make myself feel better."

The Spirit has decided it's time for them to bring their sins into the light and deal with them, and you are the lucky person who's been chosen to help them ...

article Preview

This article is currently available to subscribers only. To continue reading:

free newsletter

Sign up for our free Small Groups Newsletter : Regular access to innovative training resources, Bible-based curriculum, and practical articles.


How Should I Handle Issues with Group Dynamics?
How Should I Handle Issues with Group Dynamics?
Strategically lead your meetings so everyone feels safe, heard, and valued.
Talking About Race
When discussing race feels overwhelming, start by reflecting on your experiences and sharing your story.
My Small Group Meets in a Bar
My Small Group Meets in a Bar
How two men have created a small group for men who—let’s be honest—usually don’t like small groups
Safe Small Groups for Questions and Doubts
Safe Small Groups for Questions and Doubts
How Alpha has created a radically safe environment to be real
Share Your Story
Share Your Story
Telling our story—and listening to others’ stories—transforms us.
Four Levels of Connection for Healthy Groups
Four Levels of Connection for Healthy Groups
Move your group beyond the basics to compelling community.