Questioning Discipleship

Why group leaders should be less information-dumpers and more question-askers.

Note: In the next few weeks, we'll be introducing some "blogging all stars" from the world of small-groups ministry. Heather Zempel fits that description. She is Pastor of Discipleship at National Community Church, and she has been training group leaders for a long time on her own blog: Wineskins for Discipleship.

Henri Nouwen said, "We have to keep looking for the spiritual questions if we want spiritual answers." I used to think that my job as a small-group leader was to gather and dispense information. I thought small-group leadership was about controlling the message and making sure everyone knew the right answers to questions. However, the longer I plow the ground of spiritual growth, the more I'm convinced that discipleship boils down to the questions we ask more than the answers we give.

I've never researched it, but I'd love to know the percentage of Scripture devoted to Jesus' questions vs. Jesus' teaching. I bet the percentage looks a lot different from the amount of time the typical pastor engages in both of those activities. Consider the following:

  • Who you say that I am?

Those are some of the questions Jesus asked, and they transformed the lives of the people that he asked them to. He asked questions that are confusing, disturbing, realigning, and transforming.

Discipleship is often seen as giving people spiritual answers. It's downloading information. It's teaching. It's cramming in. But is it possible that discipleship has less to do with cramming in and more to do with drawing out? In the four Gospels, Jesus asked 307 questions. And He only answered 3 of the 183 questions that were asked of him.

The more I lead small groups and disciple people, the less I consider my job portfolio as dispenser of information. Rather, I view it as question asker. I'm beginning to use questions as the primary vehicle for disciple-making. They presuppose relationship, build trust, and invite us to explore deeper places of the mind and heart.

This isn't a new approach. Jewish rabbinical training was built on the exchange of questions. John Wesley's "classes" of the Methodist movement used a list of questions to give structure to their small group meetings.

Here are some of the questions I'm asking:

  • Where do you see God most at work in your life?

  • What is something you are excited about in your life right now?

  • What is a big challenge you are facing right now?

  • What fruit of the Spirit is most abundant in your life? What fruit of the Spirit is least abundant in your life?

  • What is stopping you from doing what you know God has called you to do?

My hope is that asking great questions will move discipleship outside the classroom context and into our every day conversations.

Free Newsletter

Sign up for our Weekly newsletter: Regular access to innovative training resources, Bible-based curriculum, and practical articles.


Digital Discipleship

Digital Discipleship

Connecting with Jesus and others in the midst of COVID-19
Discipling When Your Group Can’t Meet Due to COVID-19

Discipling When Your Group Can’t Meet Due to COVID-19

Keeping small groups connected while social distancing
Embracing the Unsatisfied Life

Embracing the Unsatisfied Life

Building sustainable faith in your small group
How to Increase Regular Commitment to Small Groups

How to Increase Regular Commitment to Small Groups

4 principles we can learn from the early church


Who has impacted you?

Famous Mentor

Who would you spend a day with?