Why Dividing Small Groups Is a Dumb Idea
Image: Andriy Onufriyenko | Getty

Why Dividing Small Groups Is a Dumb Idea

A commonsense look at a highly debated principle of small-group life

Dividing small groups is a dumb idea.

I know. Dumb is a strong word. But now that I've got your attention, let's see if you don't come to the same conclusion after we've looked more closely at this strategy's underlying rationale and unintended consequences.

For decades it's been an unquestioned canon within the small-group movement that healthy groups multiply by continually growing and splitting into new groups. Groups that stay together too long are considered stagnant. Those that fail to aggressively add new members are written off as uncommitted to the Great Commission. Any group that insists on remaining together gets tagged as selfish.

Admittedly, dividing to multiply is an idea that looks good on paper. It sounds great at leadership conferences. It's organic, mirroring the cellular growth of the human body. It offers the potential for unlimited kingdom expansion. It encourages people to reach out to the lost. It forces new leaders to step up and take the reins.

No wonder most small group gurus, church consultants, and pastors with a passion for evangelism and church growth swear by the concept.

But what about those who are in a small group? Fact is, they tend to see it differently—very differently. They generally hate the idea. They don't swear by it. They swear at it.

If you don't believe me, start asking people in churches where small groups are pressured to multiply by dividing. Ask them what they think of the empty chair they're supposed to fill during each session, and the expectation that they'll help grow the church by growing and then dividing their group.

Except for pastors, staff members, and church leaders who are professionally responsible for the growth of the ...

article Preview

This article is currently available to SmallGroups.com subscribers only. To continue reading:

Free Newsletter

Sign up for our Weekly newsletter: Regular access to innovative training resources, Bible-based curriculum, and practical articles.


Celebrate the End

Celebrate the End

Activities to bring closure and build excitement for the future
When and How to End Well

When and How to End Well

Learn how to end your group in a healthy way.

How to Give Away Your Small Group

A new strategy for trauma-free multiplication

Cell Biology for the Church

Why small groups don't multiply


Downsizing can be a scary word—but it's sometimes good to break large groups into smaller groups.